Troubleshooting Email-to-Ticket Conversion After HubSpot Move
After moving from HubSpot, emails may stop turning into tickets. This guide walks through the most common causes — DNS records, forwarding rules, spam filters — and shows how to verify and fix each one.
On this page
After a HubSpot migration, the most visible symptom is that incoming emails no longer appear as tickets in your new helpdesk. The mailbox still receives mail, but the automatic conversion step fails silently. Below are the likely causes, ordered from most to least common, with a quick way to confirm each one and the steps to resolve it.
1. DNS MX, SPF, or DKIM records still point to HubSpot
How to confirm
- Run a DNS lookup for your domain’s MX record (e.g.,
dig MX yourdomain.com). The answer should list the mail server of your new helpdesk, not HubSpot. - Check SPF and DKIM TXT records. They must authorize the new sending host. How to fix
- Update the MX record to the hostname supplied by your new helpdesk.
- Replace the SPF record with one that includes the new provider’s
include:mechanism. - Add or update the DKIM selector and public key provided by the new system.
- Allow up to 48 hours for propagation, then send a test email.
2. Email forwarding rule still points to HubSpot
How to confirm
- In your email admin console (Google Workspace, Microsoft 365, or your hosting panel), review any forwarding addresses set on the support mailbox.
- Send a test message to the support address and watch the delivery path in the message headers. How to fix
- Remove or edit the forwarding rule so it points to the new helpdesk’s inbound address.
- If you used a catch‑all forward, replace it with a dedicated alias for the new system.
- Verify by sending another test email and confirming a ticket appears.
3. Spam, quarantine, or security filters block inbound mail
How to confirm
- Check the spam or quarantine folder in the source mailbox for messages that should have become tickets.
- Review any third‑party security gateway logs (Proofpoint, Mimecast, etc.) for blocked or held messages. How to fix
- Whitelist the new helpdesk’s inbound IP ranges or sender domains in the gateway.
- Adjust spam‑filter sensitivity for the support address.
- Release any quarantined test messages and confirm they convert.
4. Inbox connection or authentication issues in the new helpdesk
How to confirm
- Open the helpdesk’s email integration settings and look for a connection status indicator (often labeled “Connected”, “Error”, or similar).
- Review the integration logs for authentication failures (OAuth token expiry, IMAP/SMTP password mismatch). How to fix
- Re‑authorize the OAuth connection or re‑enter IMAP/SMTP credentials.
- Ensure the mailbox allows less‑secure apps or app‑specific passwords if required.
- Test the connection using the helpdesk’s built‑in “Send test email” button.
5. Ticket creation rules or filters misconfigured
How to confirm
- In the helpdesk, examine any automation rules that create tickets from email (e.g., “Only create ticket if subject contains ‘Support’”).
- Send a test email that matches the expected criteria and one that does not. How to fix
- Adjust the rule logic so that all legitimate support emails meet the criteria.
- Disable overly restrictive filters temporarily to isolate the problem.
- Save changes and run another test.
If nothing worked
- Collect the full message headers from a test email that failed to convert.
- Open a support ticket with your new helpdesk provider and attach those headers.
- Ask them to trace the inbound path on their side.
- As a temporary workaround, forward the support mailbox manually to a colleague who can create tickets until the root cause is resolved.
For a step‑by‑step migration checklist that covers DNS, forwarding, and mailbox setup, see How to Migrate from HubSpot to Free Email Ticketing. If the issue looks like a forwarding problem, the guide on Troubleshooting Missing Tickets After Email Forwarding may help. For general Gmail‑specific conversion failures, refer to Troubleshooting Email to Ticket Conversion Failures in Gmail.
If you need a free helpdesk that includes email‑to‑ticket conversion, shared inbox, AI reply suggestions, and ticket status tracking without per‑agent fees, try NeuraDesk free.
Join teams already using NeuraDesk
Ready to get started?
Create your workspace and try NeuraDesk for free.
Sign up free